The Trial of a Time Lord

Series -3
Doctor Who goes full courtroom drama.
Doctor Who goes full courtroom drama.
About Time
Began 6 September 1986
Ended 6 December 1986
Series guide
Previous Next
Season 22 Season 24

Season 23, alternately known by its umbrella title The Trial of a Pie Lord, was a 14-part season-long arc of Doctor Who. It marked the final season for a ton of GOAT people in the cast and crew (such as Pie Lord as Doka, Nicholas Briggs as tiddies, Rob Holmes as alive, and Seaweed as script editor), ergo making it the last canon season of Classic Who until Season 25.


The Sixth Doctor is brought to Gallifrey and put on trial by the Time Lords for crimes against fashion. The charges also include genocide (one of the Doctor's favourite hobbies). A mysterious chap called the Lumberyard acts as prosecutor - he is later revealed to be an evil future version of the Doctor.

Peri leaves and Mel shows up during this season, but only halfway through, so at least the first two stories are watchable.

Serials of Season 23

While Trial is technically one big story and, if one were to follow that logic, the longest Doctor Who story in terms of episode amount, the storyline is split up into four separate segments that are distinct enough that parts of the fandom (aka. intelligent fans) consider it four serials glued together.

Episode Title Written By Description
The Mysterious Pie Robert Holmes The Sixth Doctor is made to witness a never before seen underrated GOAT adventure from his past as part of a trial by some shady prick to prove that he ain't good for the universe and should be put to death.
MindPie Philip Martin The Sixth Doctor is made to witness a never before seen GOAT adventure that he just had prior to the trial where Peri was kill (oh, erm... spoilers) to prove that he ain't good for the universe and should be put to death.
Terror of the Pievoids Pip & Jane Baker The Sixth Doctor tries to defend himself by showing an adventure from his future to prove that he is good for the universe (which should be breaking a couple laws of time in itself), which ends up backfiring on him.
The Ultimate Pie Robert Holmes/Pip & Jane Baker Elements from the three previous segments are neatly tied together in this thrilling conclusion and the Trial storyarc reaches a perfect and satisfying end... least, it would've had Bob not died halfway through the writing and JNT not given the reigns to Shitty McShit faces for the final episode.


The Trial Of A Pie Lord DVD.jpg

Shit went haywire during production including the death of scriptwriter Robert Holmes, the resignation of script editor Eric Sour'd and ended with the firing of Baked Colon. On the bright side though, we got an awesome one season theme tune by Dominic Glynn.


Law and Order: Time Lord Unit received Series 8-esque reception - it's good but many people are too autistic to see it. The Mysterious Planet has based Sabalom Glitz and is a pretty comfy story. Mindwarp is pretty good too, with episode 4's cliffhanger being probably one of the finest in the program's history.

The rest of the season would've been fine if Mel didn't exist and PippinJain Baker could write a decent conclusion.

Eras of Doctor Who

Season 1Season 2Season 3Season 4Season 5Season 6Season 6BSeason 7Season 8Season 9Season 10Season 11Season 12Season 13Season 14Season 15 • Season 16 (The Key to Time) • Season 17Season 17BSeason 18Season 19Season 20Season 21Season 22Season 23 (The Trial of a Time Lord) • Season 24Season 25Season 26Season 26B

BBVBig Finish ProductionsComicsDeath Comes to TimeDeviousDimensions in TimeDoctor Who MagazineDoctor Who: Last of the Time LordsLost in the Dark DimensionReeltime PicturesScream of the ShalkaShalka DoctorTV MovieThe Curse of Fatal DeathThe StrangerVirgin New Adventures

Series 1Series 2Series 3Series 4Series 4 SpecialsSeries 5Series 6Series 7Series 7 SpecialsSeries 8Series 9Series 10Series DubsSeries 12Series 13Series 14Series 16Series 17